Monday, January 23, 2023

52 Ancestors Week 4 (Jan. 22-28): Education

Education is a topic that I felt ill-prepared to write about. I may need some schooling myself. First, I agonized about which ancestor to choose. Then I realized that I haven't done much research about my ancestors' educational attainment at all. Information about their schooling was merely auxilary facts, possibly noted when researching, but likely overshadowed by dates, places, and relationships. I've never taken the steps to write about anyone's educational history as a cohesive story. If I've previously found an ancestor who was a teacher, I do not recall one this week.  

My maternal grandfather had a masters degree in mechanical engineering from the Technical University in Berlin. My paternal grandparents both graduated from high schools in Indianapolis. I'm not so sure I'd know where any of my great-grandparents attended school. Plus, did I ever stop and really look closely at that census schedule? What was their highest level of education? I didn't even know which high school my paternal grandmother's sister attended. I knew that my grandmother attended and graduated from Shortridge High School since I had seen her high school yearbook photo. But what about her older sister Libby? After some digital collection searching, the mystery was solved. Elizabeth"Libby" Davie attended Arsenal Technical High School, appearing in the 1931 yearbook.


It is always interesting to see the census schedule data columns that denote whether someone could read or write. It can be equally puzzling when first viewing a document where someone had to make "their mark" because they could not sign their name. 

Going even further back on my family tree, it became obvious that my 3x great-grandmother Rebecca Jane Gibson Maynard could not write her own name and likely could not read. When I found the probate file from her second husband, she had signed "her X mark" on the court papers. She initially had been appointed the administratrix, however, she soon had someone else take on the task, namely, her father Jasper N. Gibson. With ten children, how would she have the time to file all of the paperwork anyway? 

It is likely as a child that Rebecca Jane didn't have much opportunity to even attend school in Marion County, Indiana. This was a time when the public school system was nearly nonexistent. There was a book (published by the Genealogical Society of Marion County) with the title, Student Lists from Warren Township, Marion County, Indiana, 1856-1865, which was definitely a source to check. Unfortunately, Rebecca Jane Gibson was not listed. There is hope that some of her cousins and neighbors were able to attend school since the lists contain other Gibsons, Groves, and McVeys.  

In the school of life, it is certain that Rebecca Jane was well-educated. She'd raised 10 children, outlived four husbands, witnessed the Civil War, and lived into the Great Depression. 



Monday, January 16, 2023

52 Ancestors Week 3 (Jan. 15-21): Out of Place

Was Henry William Lieberherr (1868-1933) out of place in 1900? Maybe. He was listed in the 1900 U.S. Census as an inmate of the Indiana State Prison North at Michigan City. That wasn't necessarily where I expected to find him, but he was one of two brothers of my 2x great-grandmother Katherine Lieberherr Davie (1870-1936). 

When I initally found this information in 2012, I sought out more details about the circumstances. The Indiana State Archives holds prisoner records, so I requested those. The inmate register indicates that he was sentenced in Shelby County on March 28, 1899 for 2 to 21 years for perjury. On the prison record, it lists Henry's age as 31, his nationality as German-American, both parents born in Germany. He was unmarried, could read and write, occupation common laborer, and arrested two times before. His mother Christina Lieberherr was listed in the family section of the record.

What were the circumstances leading to Henry's charge of perjury? In 2012, I didn't find much when I looked in the Shelbyville newspaper on microfilm, only discovering a brief mention that the Sheriff was taking him up to Michigan City. He was received at the prison on April 26, 1899.

As part of 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks, I re-ran some searches and re-examined previous results in 
digitized newspapers and found more information about the trial and who else was involved. It shows that there is always more to discover.

Indianapolis News 13 Feb 1899 p.2

Digitized newspapers are the best! I'm pleased with the collection available freely through Hoosier State Chronicles. I kept searching and found this earlier information about "Kid" Whitney.

Indianapolis News  4 Jan 1899 p. 9

How did Henry W. Lieberherr meet up with John "Kid" Whitney? It appears that Whitney was pretty sure he'd have an alibi according to this article from September 22, 1898. Quote: "He says he will establish an alibi." Would Whitney pay someone to establish an alibi? 

Indianapolis News 22 Sep 1898 p. 6
Who would be stupid enough to agree to lie in court? Well... how about Henry Lieberherr? Was he merely a stooge in this whole story? After he'd been in prison for two and a half years, he was paroled on October 1, 1901. There were conditions that he kept a job and stayed out of trouble. He was returned to prison on a parole violation in January 1903. He was released on parole again in March 1905 and was discharged a year later. Interestingly, John "Kid" Whitney was initially sent to the State Reformatory at Jeffersonville before being transferred to the State Prison in 1900. Whitney was no stranger to the state prison, having been there in 1896 for a conviction in Marion County.   

I have yet to fully explore the court records of the original trial of the robbery and assault of Mary Ann Nugent. The newspaper articles hint at several more shady characters who could have been Henry Lieberherr's friends or acquaintances. Maybe he couldn't break his old habits. Henry's life story includes an absent father (Henry Sr.) who either ran off or died without leaving a trace or both. This troubling family history includes brother George's untimely death by overdose. Painful stories like these are no doubt why people will make the choice not to remember. 

Sunday, January 8, 2023

52 Ancestors Week 2 (Jan. 8-14): Favorite Photo

 My favorite photo is of Rebecca Jane Gibson Maynard (1843-1938), my 3x great grandmother. Her photo appeared in the Indianapolis Star (June 4, 1938) on the occasion of her 95th birthday. 

The photo shows her seated in an upholstered chair. She's wearing a long-sleeved dress made of a dark fabric with a light pattern. She has on lace-up boots. Her hair is pulled back. She holds a booklet tightly in her likely arthritic hands. She appears to be a spry woman who has earned her 95 years through hard work, sacrifice, and endurance.   

The photo caption provides several details of her life, most of which match up with genealogy research that I'd already worked on. I probably could go back and start counting the grandchildren, etc. 

  • She has lived in Ohio and Indiana.
  • Current residence at 740 East 14th Street.
  • 13 children, 6 living
  • 47 grandchildren
  • 36 great-grandchildren
  • 4 great-great-grandchildren
  • Rebecca was born in Ohio.
  • She lived in Johnson County, Indiana for 65 years.
  • She moved to Indianapolis two years prior to 1938.
What the photo and caption don't tell us is that she was abandoned by her first husband and had to file for divorce to be able to remarry. The Marion County court papers said that George Richards abandoned his wife and young daughter. He never responded to the complaint and Rebecca Jane was granted the divorce. She went on to marry Greenberry Mullinix of Johnson County. She outlived Greenberry, her third husband Henry Magsam, and also her fourth husband William Maynard. She lived in White River Township on land that she'd received as a widow of Greenberry.

Here is her photo which I've colorized. The chair she sat in might be red and I'd like to image that her dress was navy. 


Wednesday, January 4, 2023

52 Ancestors Week 1 (Jan. 1-7): I'd Like to Meet...

I'd like to meet Christina Buchter Lieberherr (1844-1921) and learn about the events of her life. Where was she born? Was it somewhere in Bavaria, the Palatinate or Baden? She was the oldest daughter of George Buchter and Anna Barbara Lang Buchter. The family mysteriously showed up in Indianapolis around 1858, and I've yet to find them on any ship's passenger list. 


Dear great-great-great grandmother Christina, where were you born? 
Why did your parents leave the old country and come to America?
Why are you listed on an alien enemy registration in Indianapolis in 1918?

...additional names omitted...


                           ...

(Source: Indianapolis Star, 26 June 1918, page 11)


Did your father George not naturalize before his death in 1879?
What was your life in Indianapolis like?
What happened to your husband Henry Lieberherr?

There are probably additional sad and difficult events to ask her about...her sons Henry W. (1868-1933) and George (1869-1904) had very troubled lives. Her daughter Katherine Lieberherr Davie (1870-1936) is my 2x great grandmother.

I have so many questions...

#52Ancestors


52 Ancestors for 2023!

I'm reviving my long-neglected genealogy blog with a lot of inspiration from the 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks (2023 edition) challenge! Let the stories of ancestors commence!

https://www.amyjohnsoncrow.com/52-ancestors-in-52-weeks-themes-2023/